Thanksgiving
My favorite holiday ever! It's a time for abundance, and unfortunately too many people go hungry on this day. I challenge you to be frugal with your own feast this year, and donate the surplus of what you'd normally spend to those less fortunate.
In the spirit of the "Meals on a Budget" theme on this blog, I'll share how we experience abundance on a less-than-abundant budget. As a teaser, I'll just say we did ALL of our shopping both for Thanksgiving and for the rest of next week (since leftovers will feature predominantly next week) today and walked out of the (multiple) stores with less than $75 of groceries. The image above? Oh, that's just all the stuff I couldn't find a spot for in the fridge afterwards.... :-) Yes, those oranges are huge.
The plan:
First, I'll share the menu complete with recipes and ingredient costs. I'll toss in some tips on how to keep costs down in this post, as well. Then, I'll show photographs of the pre-game prep, since everyone knows you start cooking the day before Thanksgiving. I'll show photographs as I walk you through our game-day prep, and then the "spread" which will really be individual photographs of each dish because for us, Thanksgiving is an all-day food fest, not a single sit-down meal. Finally, if I'm not too lazy and comatose from all the food, I'll show you how we used the leftovers throughout the week.
The menu:
- Asparagus with lemon and a poached egg: As unconventional as this dish sounds, I tried it one year on a whim and it has become the staple first course of the day. This dish is served typically at around 10AM in our house, consistent with its high-class breakfast-y appeal. Unfortunately, this is not the correct season for asparagus, so it's not the cheapest most frugal way to go, but it is tradition now.
- Antipasti (nuts, olives, and cheese): This is more conventional, and while costly it is tradition and I have some tips for keeping the cost down some. I put these out at around 11AM when we are starting to get munchy again.
- Salad: One year I tried a simple arugula salad dressed simply with olive oil, lemon juice, and salt. It was astounding. Again, not the cheapest most frugal dish, but definitely tradition and just wonderful in its simplicity. I serve this at around noon.
- Turkey with stuffing and cranberry sauce: This is not only tradition, but probably the cheapest route at Thanksgiving due to the multiple promotions available, especially if you are smart with your choices and willing to do a little extra prep-work yourself. This will go out at around 1 or 2 PM.
- Potatoes and green beans: Due to a sale of 10 lbs of russets for $1, we'll be mashing potatoes ourselves rather than buying them freeze-dried. Additionally, due to a lack of desire for traditional green bean casserole, I'll be making long beans with a mushroom cream sauce. Yum! (And cheaper than buying all those cans.) We'll move to this course after the turkey has digested, maybe 3 or 4 PM.
- Desert: I had a special request for pumpkin bread this year, so that is what desert will be!
- Bread: I made bread tonight in prep for stuffing tomorrow - if you like artisinal fresh breads (and who doesn't?), it is definitely cheaper to bake your own. If you're happy with Wonderbread, and I know plenty of people who are, it can be cheaper to buy pre-fabbed. However, after the bread came out of the oven fresh, a little raccoon got into the kitchen and ate half the loaf, so I'll be showing you a super-fast way to make really good bread tomorrow. That darn raccoon!
Itemized costs:
Note: Costs are prorated for feeding 8 people at your feast)
Asparagus with poached egg ($10.30, or $1.29 / person)
- Asparagus, about 1/4 lb per person ($3.99 / lb, from Sprouts, or roughly $8 total)
- Eggs, 1-2 per person ($3.39 / 18, from Super King, or roughly $2.25 total)
- Lemon juice ($0.05 per lemon, from Super King)
- Salt, pepper (nearly free)
- Olive oil, 1 Tbsp (nearly free if you buy bulk)
Bring a large pot of water to a boil with a small handful of salt added. Snap the ends off the asparagus, and add the ends to your frozen veggie stock hoard. Toss the asparagus in the boiling water, let the water return to a boil for about 1 min. Remove the asparagus from the water and immediately plunge into ice water. Return the water to a boil, then reduce to a simmer. Heat 1 Tbsp olive oil in a large skillet while poaching eggs one at a time. If you don't know how to poach an egg, don't worry, I'll teach you later, or you can look it up on youtube. Saute asparagus in olive oil for 1-2 min until reheated thoroughly. Serve by placing the asparagus all lined up the same way in a small clump with one or two poached eggs on top. Sprinkle liberally with lemon juice, add salt and pepper to taste.
Antipasti ($22.72 / 8 people, or $2.84 / person)
- Nuts: I buy these whole, still in the shell. It's more fun to eat them if you have to crack them and pick them yourself, and cheaper because a really large bowl of nuts in the shell is a lot less nuts than a large bowl of shelled nuts, and your guests don't plow through them as quickly. ($3.99 / lb, Sprouts)
- Olives: I confess, I actually buy some of these the most expensive way possible: from the deli counter at Von's. However, I supplement these with pickles and olives purchased bulk. This makes for a mid-level cost but highly-abundant-appearing appetizer. ($8.99 / lb, Von's)
- Cheese: Nothing appears more decadent than a plain wooden cutting board laden with multiple types of cheese. Nothing could be more expensive than buying 5 normal-sized blocks of cheese for $5-$10 each. However, at Ralph's you can buy small "sampler" portions of cheese for $1-2 each, making this high-end-looking appetizer much easier on your check book. ($9.74 for about 1.5 lb cheese, 5 varieties, Ralph's)
Salad ($5.04 / 8 people, or $0.63 / person)
This salad could be made with any lettuce that happens to be cheap, but gosh darn it, it's Thanksgiving and I wanted my arugula. I could've made this with red and green lettuce from Super King for less than a dollar total, but hey.
- Arugula, about 1 lb for 8 people ($4.99 / lb, Sprouts)
- Lemon juice ($0.05 / lemon, Super King)
- Salt, pepper, olive oil (nearly free in bulk)
Toss arugula with lemon juice, olive oil, salt, and pepper to taste. (Super simple!!)
Turkey ($8.80 total, or $0.55 / person given that each person really should only eat 1 lb of turkey, leaving you 8 lbs leftovers)
Ahh, turkey. Let's start with some tips. First of all, in case you haven't noticed, all your local mainstream chains are running really good deals on Turkey with offers like, "Spend $50, get a free turkey!" and the like. I would recommend you get a flier from each store in your area, and spend maybe 15-20 minutes going through them in detail to find out which offers you the truly best deal. If you already know you're going to spend $50 on items from a store offering a free turkey, by all means go for it. Our best deal was "spend $15, get a 12-16 lb turkey for $8." Or something like that. So we stocked up on their store-brand diet soda, which was also on sale, and other items they sold exclusively or more cheaply than Super King or Sprouts. This is one area of the Thanksgiving meal where you'll probably get your best deal at a higher-end, more "mainstream" store than a local ethnic-foods market.
- Turkey (16 lbs / $8, Von's)
- 1 G chicken stock (homemade from chicken bones saved from whole roasted chickens, nearly free)
- 1 head of garlic ($1.49 / lb, Super King, or $0.10 for the recipe)
- 1 piece of ginger ($0.05)
- 1.5 tsp allspice berries (nearly free in bulk)
- 1 Tbsp black peppercorn (nearly free in bulk)
- 1 c salt (nearly free in bulk)
- 1/4 c brown sugar (nearly free in bulk)
- 1 apple ($0.20, Super King)
- 1 lemon ($0.05 / lemon, Super King)
- 1 cinnamon stick ($0.05 in bulk, Concord Produce)
- 5 fresh sage leaves ($0.35, Super King)
Make a brine by boiling 1 G chicken or veggie stock with garlic, ginger, allspice, peppercorn, salt, and brown sugar. Once the salt and sugar has dissolved, boil a further 5-10 minutes. Add a bunch of ice to chill the brine to the point where it won't cook the turkey. Add the thawed turkey (with innards removed) to the brine, and add water to cover. Stick in the fridge for 1-2 days. Wash the turkey and pat dry, then stuff with everything that's left. Roast as normal.
Stuffing ($3.32 total, or $0.42 / person)
The stuffing I will make this year is inspired by the Food Network, a desire to continue to try new stuffing recipes until I find one I actually like, the overall agenda of "Meals on a Budget," and my adherence to Weight Watchers that says vegetables are "free." Therefore, I'm trying a stuffing based on homemade bread, homemade chicken stock, and roasted vegetables. I'm not entirely sure how this is going to work out yet, so here's my general plan.... subject to change, of course!
- 2 loaves homemade bread (Assuming a bunch of stuff considering I bought my flour a long time ago and can't go back to receipts to make this calculation, which would be challenging anyway because I don't know how much flour I actually use on two loaves of bread, let's say about $0.60.)
- 1/2 lb carrots, peeled, rough-chopped ($0.20, Super King)
- 1 lb turnips, peeled, rough-chopped ($0.79, Super King)
- 1 lb yams, peeled, rough-chopped ($0.19, Super King)
- 1 lb onions, peeled, some rough-chopped, 1/2 c diced ($0.40, Super King)
- 1 lb acorn squash, peeled, rough-chopped ($0.79, Super King)
- 2 stalks celery, diced ($0.10, Super King)
- Chicken stock (homemade, nearly free)
- 1-2 eggs (~$0.25, Super King)
As you can see, I'm being overly ambitious here in how many veggies I can cram into a single recipe for stuffing. We'll see how this turns out.... Anyway, the idea is to roast the veggies until golden in an oven set to 425, maybe half an hour? Then I'll mix those with toasted, cubed homemade bread, as much as I have left after the raccoon in the kitchen is done with his thievery. I'll beat an egg, mix that with the chicken stock, and pour that over everything. I'll probably also add some herbs or something. This I'll bake with the turkey for half an hour, covered, and then a further half an hour, uncovered. Maybe I'll like stuffing this year! Probably not, however. As you can see, this recipe is, as yet, a work in progress.
Cranberry Sauce ($3 total, or $0.38 / person)
I hope homemade cranberry sauce is cheaper than buying from a can, but even if it's not, I'd still make it from scratch. I never liked the canned stuff enough to eat it, but I love the homemade stuff way too much. This recipe is straight from Alton Brown of the Food Network, but I'm using Splenda 1 for 1 instead of honey.....
- 4 c fresh cranberries ($2.50, Von's. Super King didn't have any!)
- 1/4 c orange juice (free, because I had to buy this when Tim was sick and neither of us drink OJ when we are well)
- 1/4 c cranberry juice (pure, not a cocktail, $4.49 for a large amount, but I'll really only ever use the 1/4 c for this recipe.... anyway, let's say $0.50)
- 1 c Splenda (you should use honey, but I have a huge bag of Splenda hanging out and I don't mind trying it this year to help curb caloric intake, so we'll say "free" because that bag of Splenda's been hanging around without much to do for years now)
Boil juices and Splenda together for 5 minutes, making sure the Splenda dissolves. Add cranberries, simmer for less than 15 minutes - anything over will destroy the natural pectins and result in a runny sauce. Put it in the fridge overnight..... Hopefully yum!!
Mashed Potatoes ($0.25 total, or $0.03 per person)
I'm getting really tired of writing right now.... so let's assume you know how to make mashed potatoes. All that are going into mine are:
- Russet potatoes (about $.25 worth given that the 10 lb sack was only $1)
- Seasonings
Sure, the seasonings cost something, but they're like butter and dehydrated milk and garlic powder and stuff I just can't bring myself to care about right now. They're mashed russets. They're pretty darn cheap unless you do something crazy like add shaved truffle and gold powder or something.
Long Beans with Mushroom Cream Sauce ($5.02 total, or $0.63 per person)
I happen to love green bean casserole. Really love it. However, if you think about it, at around $2 per can, you're looking at $6 for what, a canned casserole? We can do better, and maybe cheaper. Let's find out!
- 2 lbs long beans ($1.89, Super King)
- 6 oz mushrooms ($1.49, Super King)
- 2 Tbsp butter ($0.10, Super King)
- 2 cloves garlic (almost free, Super King)
- 5 sage leaves ($0.35, Super King)
- 1 c heavy cream ($1, Super King)
- 1/2 leek, chopped ($0.19, Super King)
Saute garlic, sage, and mushrooms in butter until softened. Pour in cream, heat slowly. Stir in leek and blanched long beans. Salt and pepper to taste.
Pumpkin Bread ($3.37 total, or $0.42 per person)
I got this recipe from my mother-in-law because the other palate in the household positively loves this bread. It's rather cute, actually, and I must say the recipe does make a darn good bread. I hope she doesn't mind me sharing her secrets here, on the internet.... :-) If you do mind, I'm sorry, Mom! Let me know and I'll take this down ASAP!
- 3 eggs ($0.57, Super King)
- 1.5 c sugar (who knows?! Let's say $0.20 as a generous estimate)
- 1.5 c canned pumpkin (let's just say $2 for argument's sake)
- 1 c + 2 Tbsp oil (Again, who knows?! Let's be generous again and estimate $0.20)
- 1.5 tsp vanilla (Jeez, if you use imitation it's nearly free)
- 2.25 c flour (Let's say $0.30)
- 1.5 tsp baking soda (Hmm, maybe $0.05?)
- 1.5 tsp baking powder (Also maybe $0.05)
- 1.5 tsp salt (nearly free)
- 1.5 tsp ground cinnamon (nearly free)
- 0.25 tsp cloves (nearly free)
- 0.25 tsp ground ginger (nearly free)
- 0.25 tsp ground nutmeg (nearly free)
Mix it all up, divide into two greased and floured pans, bake at 350 for 1 hr. Easy peasy, and not too expensive! Yay!
Total costs:
Let's go through the costs of serving 8 people:
- Asparagus appetizer / brunch: $10.30
- Antipasti: $22.72
- Salad: $5.04
- Turkey: $4.40 (for 8 people, remember we bought a turkey big enough to serve 16)
- Stuffing: $3.32
- Cranberry sauce: $3.00
- Potatoes: $0.25
- Green beans with mushroom cream sauce: $5.02
- Pumpkin bread: $3.37
That's $57.42 total, or $7.18 per person. That probably sounds like a lot, but let's remember a few things here: (1) the way I've laid out the menu above, you're feeding your guests at a steady pace throughout the day, giving them a sense of abundance throughout for only $7.18 per person, and (2) divided among a normal 3 meals, that would be about $2.39 per person per meal, which we all would be happy with. Additionally, we included high-end appetizers including olives, fine cheeses, and higher-end greens. If we were to merely substitute the higher-end olive and cheese plate and with canned olives and a block of cheddar, we'd drop our $57.42 total down to $42.69 total. Remove the arugula and substitute a cheaper green, and we're down to $37.69 total. Of course, we could also replace the asparagus appetizer with a creative grilled eggplant appetizer (eggplant is currently 3 for a dollar at Super King), and shave a further $7 off the costs, down to $30.69 total. At this point, considering that the menu is intended to feed people for an entire day, we're down to $1.27 per person per meal, which is almost as good as Jack in the Box can do.... but we're eating a lot better with a better sense of abundance than we would off a dollar menu.
Epilogue
For me, separated from a bulk of my family at Thanksgiving, the holiday is now about having the day off to cook really good food in a way I never have an excuse to throughout the rest of the year. It's all about the sense of abundance and thankfulness and joy that comes with one day of the year to not worry so much about the cost of extravagant recipes and just enjoy cooking, eating, and being with the other palate in the house. Too many people do not get to experience that, so if you choose to choose wisely in your purchasing this Thanksgiving, please remember those less fortunate than you who have no choice.
Stay hungry, my friends!